Mailing List

For all the latest news and features, sign up to receive our FREE updates by email:

Migratory Behaviour Affects The Size Of Bird Brains

Posted on 29. June, 2010.

Bookmark and Share

Scientists have known for some time that migratory birds have smaller brains than their resident relatives. Now a new study published in the March edition of the journal PLoS One looks into the reasons and concludes that the act of migrating leads to a reduced brain size.

Researchers at Centre for Ecological Research and Forestry Applications (CREAF, a Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona-affiliated centre) reconstructed the evolutionary history of one of the most numerous orders of birds, the passeriformes, a group which includes swallows, tits and crows.

One of the classic explanations of brain size is the protective brain theory, which suggests that a large brain – in comparison to body size – makes learning easier. This protects individuals from changes in the environment, such as those produced by changes in season. In the case of birds however not all species respond to seasonal changes in the same way. Migratory birds avoid these changes by travelling to less inhospitable places when conditions worsen. This is the strategy followed by swallows or cuckoos. Resident bird species stay in the same area throughout the year and face strong environmental fluctuations. Tits and crows belong to this group.

Previous studies showed that both strategies are related to differences in brain size. The problem however is that it is often difficult to discern the causes and consequences of the differences observed. CREAF researchers Daniel Sol and Núria Garcia, together with scientists from Canada and England, analysed data from 600 passerine species in regions ranging from tropical to arctic.

They confirmed that migratory birds have smaller brains than their resident counterparts. According to the protective brain theory, being a resident bird would make it easier for the brain to grow and this for example would facilitate acquiring alternative food-finding strategies for the winter months. However, the study found the opposite to be the case: being a migratory bird is what makes these birds have smaller brains.

The researchers reconstructed the evolutionary history of passerine birds and determined the sequence of evolutionary changes which most probably led to the current situation. In the case of this group of birds “the first step was changing from a resident to a migratory life and the second step was a reduction in the size of the brains of migratory birds,” says Sol. “Therefore differences in brain sizes are not caused by nature's need to provide resident species with larger brains, as suggested in the protective brain theory, but to provide migratory species with smaller brains.”

Normally a larger brain offers many advantages, however, in migratory birds natural selection has favoured smaller brains. “The brain is an organ that consumes a lot of energy and develops slowly and this can be too costly for migratory species which must travel far and have little time to reproduce,” says Sol. At the same time, the reduction in brain volume could also be caused by a decrease in cognitive functions no longer useful to migratory species. “For birds that travel a lot, exploring their surroundings produces more costs than benefits since the information which is useful in one place is not necessarily so in another. It also exposes them to more dangers. For these reasons we believe that for these species, their innate behaviour can be more useful than learned behavior,” he says.

Based on these conclusions, the authors of the research recommend an in-depth analysis of certain areas of the brain such as the pallium and telencephalon, involved in learning and behaviour innovation processes. They believe these areas could be less developed in migratory birds than in resident birds since the cost-benefit balance in these processes does not favour the species.

The complete article can be found in PLoS ONE, 2010; 5 (3): e9617 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.